Credulity — A Disposition To Believe Too Readily

 Man’s natural state is not doubt, but credulitya combination of suggestibility in the face of whatever is clearly and strongly presented, and the will-to-believe whatever is personally or socially congenial.   Harold Larrabee, 1945

It is well known that we believe what we want to believe. We prefer to believe what we prefer to be true. Francis Bacon. Our tendency to believe what “sounds right” has become a big problem today, especially in politics. In order to become a rational, mindful believer today requires paying more careful attention to the difference between opinion and fact than ever before.

This is hard to do because of the incredibly easy access to whatever is clearly and strongly presented, and whatever is personally or socially congenial. This onslaught of data feeds our disposition to believe too readily. If there is such a thing as “extreme credulity”, technology of the future may achieve it.

Although credulity has probably existed forever, I believe it is possible to say that believing whatever we want to believe is an extremely serious problem today, even dangerous to democracy, because it dominates political discourse.  Mark Twain once said: A lie can travel half way around the world while the truth is putting its shoes on. In today’s politics, this lie can travel all the way around America.

The political strategy of today seems to be: Don’t confuse me with facts, my mind is already made up. This allows believing whatever is personally or socially congenial. When today’s president speaks, he speaks with “baseless certainty” — as described by his associates. This frees him from restrictions on his opinions or beliefs. When he says something, that makes it the truth.

It seems to me that today it is important that we acknowledge that American democracy is in a credibility crisis. Something needs to be done. Who is capable of doing it? Not the president. Apparently not the congress. The overwhelming influence of credulity in today’s political discourse, needs public acknowledgement and action.

The remedy for credulity is to slow down our believing with uncertainty, which would lead to an investigation of the reality of one’s opinions AND facts. If doubt is not our natural state, it needs to be learned. Baseless certainty won’t work. My suggestion: “Confuse me with facts, so my mind can see reality.”  Facts may not be personally or socially congenial, so they challenge credulity. Political credulity needs to be challenged.

Every man prefers belief to the exercise of judgement.  Seneca

We have become so accustomed to our illusions                                                                              that we mistake them for reality.” Daniel J. Boorstin


This entry was posted in Democracy in Danger. Bookmark the permalink.


  1. Marianne says:

    While reading your blog, I realize, of course, I believe you insights and take them seriously. However, I also realize it is not about my beliefs that need to be looked at but “those” other people who are wrong thinking. Hmmmmm, maybe I need to look at that a bit closer. Surely my beliefs are “right thinking”.

  2. Carl Thoresen says:

    Hi HB
    Once again I am asking you to send a copy
    Of “Believing Dilemma “so I can hand it to the
    Men’s Fellowship Group.

    I hope all goes well and your family. Kay had a bout of sickness confining her to bed for 2 weeks. Thankfully she feeling really good!!

    It’s time for me to come up for coffee with you
    What days are open for you. I’ve been very busy in my role as Chairman of CPP, Inc. Take a look on CPP on the website.

    Be Peace,

    Carl E. Thoresen
    Professor Emeritus of
    Education,Psychology,& Psychiatry,
    Stanford University

    Senior Fellow,
    Spirituality and Health Institute
    Santa Clara University

    Chair, Board of Directors
    CPP, Inc.

    408 656 5628

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.